Original Series Cast and Key Roles
The original 1990s Canadian horror anthology series Are You Afraid of the Dark featured a core group of young actors known as the Midnight Society. The show, which first aired on Nickelodeon, centered on a group of kids who gathered around a campfire to tell scary stories. The cast became widely recognized for their roles in the recurring frame narrative and individual episodes.
The original lineup included actors such as Ross Hull as Gary, Jacob Tierney as Pete, and Rachelle Lefevre as Kelly. Other notable members of the early cast were Daniel DeSanto, Michael Yarmush, and Tamara Gorski. These actors portrayed the central group that introduced each story, maintaining a consistent presence throughout the initial run of the series.
Revival Cast and New Additions
The 2019 revival on Nickelodeon brought back the Midnight Society concept with a new generation of actors. The updated series featured a fresh cast while retaining the core structure of kids sharing spooky tales around a campfire. The revival aimed to introduce the franchise to a new audience while honoring the original format.
The 2019 cast included actors such as Lyliana Wray as Rachel, Benjamin Flores Jr. as Gavin, and Mia Bella as Kiki. Other members of the revival cast were Nathaniel Augustson, Rafael Casal, and Aria Birch. The series was produced by Nickelodeon and aired as a limited run, bringing the franchise back after years of absence.
Cast Members' Careers After the Show
Several actors from both the original and revival series went on to pursue notable careers in film and television. Rachelle Lefevre became widely known for her role in the Twilight film series, portraying the character Victoria. Her work in the franchise brought her international recognition and established her as a prominent actress in the young adult genre.
Other cast members transitioned into various roles across the entertainment industry. Jacob Tierney continued acting and expanded into directing and writing, while Daniel DeSanto appeared in projects such as the animated series Total Drama. The original and revival casts collectively represent a significant part of Nickelodeon's legacy in children's and young adult programming.